great place to sit outside with a beer (or two) - maybe after a stop at the Black Cat Books across the street.
the salmon; the beets. all delicious, big portions too. great for a fancy, special occasion dinner.
for your first lunch after you arrive at Shelter Island: a lobster roll, a Narragansett and a seat out back in the deck. (you can actually boat in as well, because why not?)
be on the lookout on their calendar for their evening concert/recital series - alumni come back to play for you (and you learn some new pieces along the way) https://perlmanmusicprogram.org/
go for the Green Trail (6 mi, 2.5 hrs) – mostly flat and just the right distance for exercise, for seeing sights. (bug, tick spray before). PDF map: https://bit.ly/2PFTDRw
quesadilla, guac - you can sit in their backyard or, better yet, take it to go and head next door to the yard at the brewery
amazing find (thanks to my friend Kathryn!) – a few bits of vinyl (we took a couple home), lots of design and photography books, old books about new york and one really amazing shelf with rare books.
this is the Everything Store on the Island for supplies you've forgotten to pack. be sure to stop in for breakfast too – and get the off-menu blueberry pancakes!
