One of my favs now are the tofu wings! Fried tofu slathered in wing sauce!!! Yummm. Beer is fantastic too. Can't go wrong with stopping here for some great pub food!
Order from the menu in the plastic stand thingy, not the folding menu. The prices are about half, and it's all good. Great beer selection. My favorite spot in New Paltz.
There are actually 3 menus. There's the restaurant menu, the beer list, and the bar menu. Also, try the Baltika 9, which is the only Russian Beer on the list!