Tyler Durden

"Snobbish service, overcooked lobster (rolls), over salted blackened fish. The crab cake was good however. If this is Montauks best, I'll never be back."

"Nothing was good."

"If you like loud obnoxious patrons, crunchy overcooked lobster (rolls), over salted blknd fish & snobbish service, this is the place for you! All told $106 f/2. I'll never be back to Montauk."

"Rad place, cheap beer and killer bier garten"

"Lump crab eggs Benedict not woth $20"

"I had the crab eggs Benedict. 1st bite I thought the E. muffin was cold and undercooked & the hollandaise sauce was lacking in flavor & sweetness. Overall the meal was forgettable and not worth $20."