Todd Merchant

"Order the Big Beef, dipped, with both kinds of peppers. The chocolate cake (shake) are decadent and life-changing."

"Everything on the menu is solid. We particularly love the cucumber quinoa salad. Great range of beer on tap."

"Great view of the bay. Fun to look at the seals below. Solid beer."

"Great clam chowder -- get it in a bread bowl. And the Green With Envy pizza was aces."

"The Reggie Deluxe is a must. If you're not into meat, get the Regina. Not to be overlooked are the available condiments -- Secret Aardvark sauce and the BBQ-esque sauce whose name I can't recall."

"Love the Gobbler and Balsamic Beef sandwiches. But everything I've ever had has been great. And you can tell everything is made from scratch. This our my favorite eatery in Madison."