Matthew Spector: Hands down the best cookie in the world. Phenomenal and a New York City standard. Also great walnut bread, chocolate brioche and banana breas. Just buy it all. The quintessential New York bakery.
Matthew Spector: Crack pue and compost cookies are the best - and don't forget they'll give you a shot of cereal milk in any coffee drink. Put an egg on a bun for their quick breakfast.
Matthew Spector: A grocery store of organized chaos. Avoid during peak times - the after work crowd is intense and they'll often turn people away if lines are too long. Fairway and Westside Market nearby are good alts
Matthew Spector: The best-kept sushi secret on the Upper West Side - amazing special rolls, any of the octopus or squid appetizers and the fish of the day. A community feel.
Matthew Spector: While service has suffered slightly, Spanish standards like paella and offerings like lobster and other seafood are still standouts. Great sangria and stuffed mushrooms.